Skip to main content

Four Conferences, Four Different Paths to the Top of PIP

Indiana sits at No. 1 in the Performance Index Poll. Miami is No. 2. Georgia is No. 3. Utah is No. 4.

· Ranktory Research

Indiana sits at No. 1 in the Performance Index Poll. Miami is No. 2. Georgia is No. 3. Utah is No. 4. Those four teams are the highest-ranked squads from the Big Ten, ACC, SEC, and Big 12 in the Week 12 edition of PIP. Each one reaches its spot a different way.

Indiana’s lead comes from having no weak on-field category. Miami’s ranking comes from elite offense and game control that outpace a middling defense. Georgia’s ranking comes from five solid columns that absorb a soft schedule. Utah’s ranking comes from results and execution that have not yet been matched by the defense or the schedule.

These are four different profiles so far. One is defense-led with no major hole. One is high-powered offense carrying the average. One is balanced across the board. One is results-and-execution driven while still undefeated. The category ranks show exactly how each one is built.

Indiana (Big Ten) — No. 1, 13.50

Indiana’s average is the lowest in the country because almost every column is strong. Defense ranks 3rd. Execution is 4th. Results sit at 7, Game Control at 13, and Offense at 16. Opponent Quality is the softest of the six at 38th.

The defense is the clearest driver. Indiana allows the fewest yards per play in FBS and ranks near the top in points and rushing yards allowed. The other categories are not elite, but none of them are dragging the average down far enough to knock the Hoosiers out of the top spot. A loss to Ohio State earlier in the season has not erased the rest of the body of work so far.

Miami (FL) (ACC) — No. 2, 14.67

Miami’s ranking is carried by two of the six categories and limited by one. Game Control ranks 1st. Offense ranks 2nd. Results are 7th and Execution is 16th. Defense sits at 29th. Opponent Quality is 33rd.

The offense continues to produce one of the highest points-per-game averages in the country. The Game Control numbers follow from that. The defense has not matched that level so far, which is the main reason Miami sits a clear step behind Indiana rather than level with it. The recent loss at Notre Dame is already in the data; it has not been enough to move Miami out of second.

Georgia (SEC) — No. 3, 16.33

Georgia’s profile is the most balanced of the four. Offense ranks 1st. Execution is 2nd. Defense is 4th, Results is 7th, and Game Control is 7th. Opponent Quality is the outlier at 77th.

The five on-field categories are strong enough that the soft schedule ranking has not pushed Georgia outside the top five. The Bulldogs have not needed one dominant category to stay high; the average holds because most of the columns are already good. That is different from Miami’s more top-heavy profile and different from Indiana’s defense-led average.

Utah (Big 12) — No. 4, 18.50

Utah’s ranking rests on Results and Execution more than the other columns. Results ranks 2nd. Execution is 9th. Offense and Game Control both sit at 8th and 9th. Defense is 24th. Opponent Quality is 59th.

The undefeated record is doing real work in the Results category. Execution is also near the top of the country. The defense has not been as strong as Indiana’s or Georgia’s so far, and the schedule has not been as difficult as Alabama’s or Ohio State’s. Those two factors are why Utah sits fourth rather than higher, even while remaining undefeated.

What kind of team wins it?

PIP does not answer that question. It only describes what has happened on the field through Week 11. Indiana is the defense-led team with no weak column. Miami is the high-powered offense. Georgia is the balanced one. Utah is the results-and-execution team that is still undefeated.

The remaining games will change the category ranks, and the PIP will move with them. So far, these are four different ways a team can reach the top of the Performance Index Poll. Which profile, if any, ends up holding the title is still ahead of us.