Skip to main content

Why Is Indiana No. 1 in the Performance Index and No. 4 in the Polls?

PIP vs. the AP and Coaches polls, Week 9

Eight of the AP's top ten are also in PIP's top ten. Where the two split, one column explains most of it: the strength of a team's schedule.

· Ranktory Research · Polls: AP and Coaches, Week 9; PIP edition through week 8 · Data: game results through week 8

Indiana is No. 1 in the Performance Index Poll. It is No. 4 in both the AP and Coaches polls. LSU is No. 2 in PIP, and No. 15 in AP and No. 13 in Coaches. Miami (FL) is No. 1 in both polls and No. 9 in PIP.

Those are the biggest headline differences in this week's rankings. They are not the whole story, so let's start with what the two sides agree on.

Most of the top 10 is the same list

Eight of the AP's Top 10 are also in PIP's Top 10: Miami (FL), Ohio State, Georgia, Indiana, Notre Dame, Utah, BYU and Alabama. The polls and PIP do not live in different worlds. They disagree about order, and about a handful of teams.

TeamPIPAPCoaches
Indiana144
LSU21513
Ohio State322
Notre Dame456
AlabamaT-51010
BYUT-589
Houston71819
Georgia833
Miami (FL)911
Utah1065

PIP is the Week 9 edition (games through Week 8). AP and Coaches are the Week 9 polls.

How does Indiana get to No. 1?

PIP uses statistics only. Each team gets a rank in six categories, and its PIP Score is the average of those six ranks (lower is better). By this point in the season all six count equally, which is easy to check: Indiana's six category ranks are 5.5, 16, 6, 1, 16 and 19.5, which average 10.67, exactly its score.

TeamResultsOffenseDefenseExecutionGame ControlOpp. QualityPIP Score
Indiana5.516611619.510.67
LSU25.5137925819.08
Ohio State92013355620.67
Miami (FL)2.511514111925.42

Indiana is not the best team in any one category except Execution, which blends third-down rates on both sides, turnover margin and penalty yards. It has no category worse than 19.5. That is the shape that wins this formula: no weak column.

Look at what Indiana actually is on the field. The Hoosiers allow 12.0 points a game (2nd of 138), 4.2 yards per play (3rd) and 73.5 rushing yards (4th), and they are 5th in fewest penalty yards. They are also 9th in scoring margin and 38th in points scored. They are 7-1, and the loss was at home to Ohio State, 19-15, a team PIP ranks below them.

PIP does not count head-to-head results, a limit we explained when PIP launched. A fan who says "Indiana lost to Ohio State, end of discussion" has a fair argument. PIP's answer is that it measures the full eight games of performance, not one result. The poll voters' answer is the opposite. Neither is a proof.

The real divider is schedule

The largest single gap in these tables is the Opponent Quality column, and it explains most of the split.

Miami (FL) leads the country in points per game (49.0), yards per play (7.8) and scoring margin (+33.7), and is 7-0. In PIP it is ninth because its Opponent Quality rank is 119th of 138. Utah (117th) and UCLA (128th), both unbeaten and in the AP's top seven, have the same drag. Georgia (101st) lands 8th in PIP against 3rd in the polls.

Indiana's opponent-quality rank is 19.5. LSU's is 58. Ohio State's is 56.

An easy way to see how much that one column matters: remove it and average only the other five categories. This is arithmetic on published numbers, not a Ranktory ranking, but the order changes.

RankFive-category average (no Opponent Quality)
1Miami (FL) 6.7
2Notre Dame 8.6
3Indiana 8.9
4Georgia 9.0
5Utah 9.1
6UCLA 10.7
7LSU 11.3
8Ohio State 13.6

Miami goes from 9th to 1st. Indiana stays near the top at 3rd. LSU drops from 2nd to 7th.

That is the observation: in PIP, the schedule is one-sixth of the score, and it is why the unbeaten teams with the lightest schedules sit below the polls' order. Whether one-sixth is the right amount is a legitimate question and not one this data can answer. Opponent Quality is also built from the other five categories of opponents, so it is a stats-based measure of schedule, not a record of who beat whom. A reader who thinks schedule should count for more, or for less, will read this table differently.

And LSU?

LSU is the PIP-side surprise. The Tigers are 6-2 and have lost twice on the road: 32-24 at Ole Miss and 35-34 at Kentucky. Neither poll has them in its top 12.

PIP's case: LSU is No. 2 in Game Control (scoring margin, yards-per-play and first-down differentials, time of possession), 6th in scoring margin at +24.1 a game, 7th in points per game, and 6th in opponent yards per play. Its two losses cost it in Results (25.5), but because PIP ranks each category and then averages, one weak column cannot sink a team that is strong in four others.

The poll case is exactly what you would expect: two losses, and a turnover margin of -2, which ranks 87th. Voters weigh results heavily. PIP, by design, does so for one-sixth of the score.

Where the polls rank teams higher than PIP does

The gap runs the other way too. The biggest cases of the polls higher than PIP, by AP rank minus PIP rank:

Kentucky: AP 9, Coaches 8, PIP 28

Ole Miss: AP 12, Coaches 12, PIP 46

Florida: AP 17, Coaches 20, PIP 50

Texas: AP 11, Coaches 11, PIP 21

Wake Forest: AP 14, Coaches 15, PIP 26

And teams PIP puts in its Top 25 that neither the AP nor the Coaches poll has ranked: Nebraska (PIP 12), New Mexico (13), Liberty (17), North Dakota State (22) and Oregon State (24).

(Texas is the opposite case for the schedule argument: its Opponent Quality rank is 3rd, the best of any ranked team, but its Offense is 77th and Execution is 93rd, so it still ends up 21st.)

What this shows, and what it does not

Shows: PIP and the polls agree on most of the top ten. Where they split, the Opponent Quality column explains most of it, and the same data that puts Indiana first puts Miami ninth.

Suggests: the AP and Coaches voters are weighing schedule less than PIP does, or weighing record more. That is a reasonable reading, not a measured one.

Does not show: that PIP's order is the right one. It does not say Indiana would beat Miami. If PIP's view of schedule is right, the evidence will show up in results over the next several weeks.

What would settle it

Three things to watch: whether Indiana and LSU keep their places through the next two or three Saturdays, how Miami (FL) does as its schedule gets harder, and how the polls and PIP converge or diverge when the season's schedule-strength numbers settle.

Explore the full PIP table, or read how PIP works.